The Old Liberal Council Fathers laughed at his sensible voice: "Quickly one leaves the safe >>old way<< -- but the new ideas may tear open before us an abyss."
(kreuz.net) The sensible Bishop Giovanni Battista Peruzzo (1963+) of Agrigento in Sicily gave a remarkable speech at the Second Vatican Council.
Actually, the Old Liberal faction sent him off with laughter.
Historian Roberto Mattei (63) wrote this in his book "The Second Vatican Council. A story untold till now".
The prize winning work appeared in December in German in the 'Edition Kirchlich Umschau'.
The anti-Liturgical Movement
Msgr Pruzzo argues historically in his assertions. He recalled the anti-Liturgical movement, which arose at the end of the 15th Century and the beginning of the 16th century.
It appeared in the circles of a heathen humanism.
The first Italian anti-Liturgists were "true and actual heathens" -- maintains the Bishop
The leadership of the movement was undertaken by humanist Erasmus von Rotterdam (+ 1536).
All anti-Liturgists showed themselves in their erratic faith: "They followed each other as brothers in competition, who would later separate themselves from the Catholic Church" -- explained the Bishop.
Finally, we arrived at the Modernists.
They had no Saints on their side.
Bishop Peruzzo insists that there is not a single sainted Bishop who promoted this movement. On the contrary, they would have bound everything to Latin tradition.
He named St. Charles Borromeo (+1584), St. Antonio Maria Claret (+1870), St. Francis de Sales (+1622) or St. Alfonsus de Ligroui (+1787).
Bishop Preuzzo stressed caution:
"One quickly leaves the >>old way<<, which is secure; but the new ideas, what abysses they loom and make ready for us."
A Prophetic Judgement
Msgr. Peruzzo cited the anti-Liturgical theories of the fallen priest Erasmus of Rotterdam.
This one found it "inopportune and comical, when the simple people and women murmured and repeated their Sunday prayers and Psalms like parrots, while they didn't understand their meaning."
The Parisian University condemned Ersasmus' theses as "Godless, erroneous and encouraging of new errors".
Bishop Peruzzo indicated these incisive condemnations as "excessive". Yet still: "They were prophetic."
Everyone, who promotes a reduction of Latin in the Liturgy, always brings the same argument -- he stated.
It is supposed that the people will "be better instructed, inspired to a greater love of God and be more faithful."
The abandonment of latin after the Pastoral Council should have fundamentally refuted this argument.
The Struggle Against Latin Leads to an Abyss
Msgr Peruzzo asserted that the Germanization of the Liturgy thorugh the Reformers was "the first act of separation from Holy Mother the Church".
He cited the famous Abbot Prosper-Louis-Geueranger (+1875) from the Benedictine Cloister of Solesmes.
He admonished, that the separation of the Liturgical language has in the past, "even if a Papal dispensation is granted, led to schism and complete separation from the Catholic Church".
Link to kreuz.net original...
Part of a Series:
Cool Headed Council Fathers Warned
Modernists Masked Themselves as the Middle Position
A Prophetic Voice at the Vatican Council
50 Theologians Petition Holy Father
No comments:
Post a Comment